Use the same test site for each plan
Keep the theme, plugins, sample media and PHP version the same when comparing hosts. Include a text page, a heavier page with representative images and a form. Save the plan name, data-centre region and cache settings so you can identify what made the difference. A five-minute demonstration on a blank home page tells you little about a busy WordPress store.
Measure from the places that matter
Sample from the regions where your visitors will come from. Test both a repeat visit with a warm cache and a fresh session, especially for search, checkout and login. Record time to first byte separately from when people can see and use the page. Check whether the slow pages are waiting on the origin, downloading heavy assets or running third-party scripts, and repeat at different times of day.
Monitor availability and dynamic pages
Put a public page under external monitoring and keep a dated failure log. Also check a representative dynamic route. A cached home page can look healthy while a database error breaks enquiries or checkout. Note whether the outage affected one location or several, and whether the host notified you before you had to open a ticket.
Restore something and see what support does
Ask support to explain how to recover a table, a media directory or an entire site. Try restoring into a separate staging site. Keep an offline copy and confirm the restoration leaves working links, permissions and database credentials. If a platform backup feature is convenient but has a short retention window, use a separate schedule that matches your recovery needs.
Make a move only when the test improves daily work
Turn the result into a short comparison sheet: response time from your region, backup retention, time to restore, hours when live support is available, and the price that applies at renewal. Those observations are enough to decide if a faster host is worth a migration, and they give you a baseline to check again after launch.